Vinegar Hill Affordable Housing

2016 National DiscoverDesign Competition: Design an affordable housing prototype

Define the Problem

Need help?

New York City is currently suffering from a massive affordable housing crisis. Fortunately for the city, it is a high priority for both the mayor and many designers, architects, and urban planners across the nation. Through this project I will work to create an affordable house for Vinegar Hill, Brooklyn, New York City, New York.

Collect Info

Need help?

Since I do not live in New York City and have only been there once, I contacted an Urban Planner by the name of Mitchel Loring (who currently lives in the city) to help me explore my options and understand New York a little better. He directed me towards several of the city's websites where I could find current housing projects and lists of neighborhoods to work with. Mr. Loring also shared personal testimonies of what it is like to live in New York City and how it is different from living in Kansas. Something else he suggested was that I take screenshots of the current are on Google Maps Street View. I used all of this, as well as the HAI Metropolitan Index to guide my way through the beginning stages of this project.

Comments

cbushorn 3 months ago
That's very helpful that you were able to contact an Urban Planner from around your location. That information he shared with you as well as the information you found would have been helpful to see more of it here. While some of it is shown, like the screenshots he recommended, including statistics (especially on the neighborhoods you looked at) or other information would help the viewer get a better understanding of New York too (for those, like me, who are unfamiliar with that place).

Brainstorm Ideas

Need help?

I went through several ideas during this step. I started with thinking about Tiny Houses because they are a huge social movement right now, but they do not fit with this area. I then moved onto single family homes, but I decided that was a waste of limited space. I finally decided on a multi level apartment building. My brainstorm drafts are not to scale, they are just rough sketches.

Develop Solutions

Need help?

Since I had chosen to move on with the multi level apartment building, my first question was how many floors tall should it be? The answer is simple, three. Three gives enough room to fit up to four families plus a couple with no children or a single adult. Anything taller than three stories starts to lose that home feeling in this neighborhood because three levels is the average size of buildings in Vinegar Hill.

Comments

ShaeSpahle 7 months ago
Though 3 stories is the average size of buildings in Vinegar Hill, is that because of tradition or because of limitations at the time of building. If it is because of limitations at the time of building, would it not be more economically beneficial to create a larger building so the cost of the land and construction is spread over more tenants? It is a forward thinking design for an apartment that promotes the use of community spaces and many families could benefit from this sort of housing in New York, but by increasing the number of levels, you can even further lower the price and make the housing accessible to more.

Final Design

Need help?

My final design is a 3-D rendering of my ideas in my develop solutions stage. They are the same for the most part with the minor exception of an added accessible roof to allow a greenhouse or garden space for all the residents to take care of and enjoy. I also decided that to keep costs down one could simply renovate the surrounding buildings to follow the design model shown below with alterations necessary for different building types.

Comments

Tannerjwashington 3 months ago
From the second floor to third floor design, how do the stairs go between those two floors?
Mattsonma 3 months ago
In one of my original designs, I had added a second stairwell right next to the first (on the second floor). I must have forgotten to copy that piece over when I created my final design. That would also slightly affect the layout of the apartment the stairwell is directly left of.
Mattsonma 3 months ago
In one of my original designs, I had added a second stairwell right next to the first (on the second floor). I must have forgotten to copy that piece over when I created my final design. That would also slightly affect the layout of the apartment the stairwell is directly left of.
Mattsonma 3 months ago
In one of my original designs, I had added a second stairwell right next to the first (on the second floor). I must have forgotten to copy that piece over when I created my final design. That would also slightly affect the layout of the apartment the stairwell is directly left of.